
Banks just had their best overdraft quarter in four years, and the timing is hard to ignore.
Reuters reported last week that U.S. banks collected about $1.6 billion in overdraft fees in the third quarter, up 9.4% from the quarter before. The numbers come from bank disclosures and were confirmed by KBRA Financial Intelligence. Fees hit an all-time low in early 2025 and have climbed 23% since then.
A few months after that low, Congress wiped out the CFPB’s overdraft rule, which would have capped fees at $5 a transaction at the biggest banks and, according to the National Consumer Law Center, saved households about $5 billion a year. Trump signed the repeal on May 12, 2025. The rule never took effect.
Reuters is careful to say the data don’t prove one thing caused the other, and I’ll be just as careful. But Adam Rust at the Consumer Federation of America told them, “It is impossible to separate what banks are charging in overdraft from what is going on at the CFPB.” That’s about as blunt as an analyst gets.
Here’s who’s collecting. JPMorgan Chase and Wells Fargo together took in $590 million, roughly what the other 20 largest banks collected combined. JPMorgan’s fees are up 32% since early 2025 and Wells Fargo’s are up 17%. Both say about three-quarters of overdrawn transactions carry no fee, which is fair to mention. It also means the rest carry one, and the FDIC says a single charge can run about $35.
I’m not a reflexive regulation guy. My test is whether a rule solves a real problem or just makes a nice press release, and this one was aimed at a real problem. The National Consumer Law Center says families paid over $12 billion in overdraft and NSF fees in 2025. These fees tend to land on people with the thinnest cushion, which is a strange group to squeeze for extra cash.
The free-market answer is also sitting right there. Capital One, Citi, Ally and American Express charge no overdraft fees at all, according to the NCLC, and Bank of America dropped its fee from $35 to $10 in 2022. Those banks stay in business. So the big fee isn’t a cost of doing business, it’s a bet that you won’t bother to leave.
It’s also worth remembering who’s cashing in. JPMorgan and Wells Fargo each took $25 billion in federal rescue money in 2008. They paid it back, and good for them. I’m still not in a mood to pity either one over a capped fee, and I wrote about the Fed’s $420 billion for Wall Street in September for the same reason. Fees stick when customers don’t walk, which is also what happened when Southwest ended free bags.
One more number. Mark Zandi at Moody’s Analytics told Reuters he wonders whether rising overdrafts are a leading indicator of developing credit problems. Inflation-adjusted wages have fallen since April. If people are overdrawing more often, that’s a warning light, and it is a strange moment for the cap to be gone.
My take: the cap was a decent idea that Congress killed, and the banks charging the most are the ones that least need the money. If you’re one of the people paying, switch banks or turn the overdraft coverage off. Your account has an exit, and some banks have been charging $0 for years.
My two cents: if a bank wants $35 to cover a $12 shortfall, it’s not a service, it’s a toll on the people who can least afford it.