Shoppers Say They’re Miserable. Retailers Still Expect the First $1 Trillion Holiday.

Crowd of Christmas shoppers on a busy shopping street

Ask Americans how the economy feels and you get a groan. Watch what they do at the register and you get a stampede.

The University of Michigan’s consumer sentiment index landed at 48.0 in October, which Forbes pegs as the second-lowest reading on record. The early read for November bounced to 51.0, a three-month high. That is still the neighborhood of “everybody is miserable.” Meanwhile the National Retail Federation, back on October 15, forecast that November and December retail sales will hit $1.013 trillion, up 4.2%, the first trillion-dollar holiday season ever.

So which is it? Both, apparently. People will tell a pollster they’re stressed and then buy a TV because it’s $200 off.

I’d put a small asterisk on that trillion, though. The NRF also predicted a trillion-dollar holiday last year, and 2025 came in at $972 billion, up 3.1%. And a good chunk of this year’s 4.2% is just prices. The NRF’s own chief economist said inflation and rising gas prices are leaning on household budgets, and the Michigan survey has people expecting prices to climb 4.3% over the next year. If that’s anywhere close, a 4.2% sales bump could mean shoppers hauling home about the same pile of stuff for more money. That’s my read, not a number anybody published, but it’s worth keeping in mind when the headlines say “record.”

The weekend crowd numbers are funnier. The NRF expects 182.7 million people to shop Thanksgiving weekend, down about 2% from the 186.9 million it forecast a year ago. Last year’s actual turnout was 203 million, nearly 10% above that forecast. The people paid to predict this keep guessing low, and shoppers keep showing up anyway.

Part of the dip is timing. The NRF says about 60% of consumers had started their holiday shopping by early November, which is exactly what Walmart’s two-weeks-early Black Friday was built to encourage. Black Friday is now a month-long mood. The retailers trained us to wait for the sale, then started the sale before the turkey was thawed.

I’m not here to scold anyone for spending money they earned. It’s theirs. Plenty of people did the same thing with their Thanksgiving travel plans: grumbled about prices, booked the flight anyway. Gripe and spend, that’s the national hobby.

But a sentiment survey measures a mood, and a checkout line measures a decision. When they disagree, I trust the checkout line every time. I just want to know whether the receipt got bigger because people bought more or because everything cost more.

My two cents: Americans say the economy is awful and then spend like it’s fine, so next time somebody quotes you a record, ask whether it’s a record of stuff or a record of prices.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

➤