Washington Will Pay Farmers a Record $55.4 Billion This Year. Who Broke the Market in the First Place?

Farmers are on track to collect a record $55.4 billion in government payments this year, according to AgWeb. The old record was $45 billion, set in 2020 when the pandemic shut the economy down.

The money has come in waves. The USDA’s $12 billion Farmer Bridge Assistance program went to more than 560,000 farmers earlier this year, and the regular ARC and PLC farm program payments added more than $13 billion in October. Then on October 19 the administration announced another $8 billion, called Harvest Fuel Relief, to help with diesel costs. Payment rates for the big row crops are supposed to arrive this month, per Talk Business.

Diesel was averaging $6.127 a gallon the week ending November 10, which is $2.29 more than a year ago, according to EIA numbers reported by FleetOwner. That is a real problem if you run a combine for a living. I don’t think farmers are the villains in this story, and I’m not going to pretend otherwise.

Here’s what bugs me. The 2020 payments made sense to me, because nobody caused a pandemic and nobody’s business decisions led to it. This round is different. Farmers got squeezed by tariffs and by a war that sent fuel and fertilizer prices up, and both of those came out of Washington. I wrote about that war and the diesel bill a while back. Now the same government is writing checks to cover the damage. One economist at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities put it about the same way, telling CBS News the relief addresses harm caused by the administration’s earlier policies.

It also isn’t small. USDA’s February forecast had net farm income at $153.4 billion, down 0.7% from last year, and it already counted $44.3 billion in direct government payments. Payments have since climbed past that. Take away the checks and the picture looks a lot weaker than the headline number.

None of this money is free. It gets added to the pile, and earlier this month I looked at the $186 billion the government sent out last year that it shouldn’t have. A system that can’t keep track of the money it already hands out is not one I want deciding how to patch a hole it dug itself.

The farm lobby is already asking Congress for more, with supporters reportedly pushing for $17 billion to $20 billion on top of all this. I get why. If somebody offers you a check to cover a problem, you take the check.

My two cents: if a policy needs a record-setting payment every year to cover what it broke, it’s not relief anymore, it’s a subscription.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

➤